The 22-year-old scored for Azerbaijani outfit Sabah FK in their 2-1 defeat to the German side on Tuesday night, marking a significant milestone in his career since leaving Amakhosi.
McCarthy, who joined Sabah from Chiefs in July, rose to head home in the 39th minute, cancelling out Dortmund’s early advantage and giving the hosts hope of securing a positive result against one of Europe’s established clubs.
Although Sabah ultimately suffered defeat, the left-footed defender was encouraged by his team’s performance and believes the match demonstrated that smaller clubs can compete against formidable opposition.
Speaking after the game, McCarthy admitted that he had not anticipated scoring but was delighted with how the opportunity unfolded.
“I never expected to score, I do not plan for these things, but it just happened in the moment and I am very happy,” he said, per AnewZ.
The former Chiefs defender also expressed confidence that his first goal for Sabah could be the beginning of many more, highlighting its significance for his development abroad.
“I am really happy with the goal I scored, and I believe that this goal will be the beginning of many goals in the future. This goal is very important for my career,” he added.
McCarthy also drew encouragement from Sabah’s ability to challenge Dortmund, despite acknowledging that lapses in concentration and missed opportunities ultimately proved costly.
“It shows that these things are possible no matter who you come up against, the ball is round and anything is possible,” he said.
“As long as you put yourself into those positions to score, it can happen and it showed it tonight.”
The defender admitted that Sabah had opportunities to make a greater impact but could not capitalise on key moments during the contest.
McCarthy and his teammates will now turn their attention to domestic football, with a league clash against Qarabag scheduled for this weekend.
Sabah are then set to resume their Champions League campaign away against Norwegian side Viking FK on 4 November, where McCarthy will hope to build on his memorable European breakthrough.
Liverpool midfielder Trey Nyoni insists there was "no panic at all" after falling behind by two goals in the Champions League clash against Villarreal, before beating the Spanish side 4-3 in a thriller at Anfield.
Kaizer Chiefs coach Fernando Da Cruz has called for unity within the club as Amakhosi look to end their winless run and rescue their CAF Confederation Cup campaign against Red Arrows at Moses Mabhida Stadium on Friday.
Senegal will have to wait until the end of November to discover whether they can reclaim the Africa Cup of Nations (AFCON) title after the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) confirmed that its ruling on their appeal would take several more weeks.
Sekhukhune United coach Papi Zothwane has warned his side that improving their defensive solidity will be crucial if Babina Noko are to compete for silverware in the 2026/27 season.
