The Spaniard left the field in the 70th minute following a collision with William Osula and was replaced by Kepa Arrizabalaga, leaving Mikel Arteta concerned about the potential loss of one of his most important players.
Raya will undergo an MRI scan, with Arteta admitting the extent of the injury remains unclear.
"Unfortunately, he had to come off, which is never good news. He will get assessed now and will probably have an MRI tomorrow to see exactly what he has done," the Arsenal manager said.
The 31-year-old has been instrumental in Arsenal's success, having played a key role in last season's Premier League title triumph and winning the Golden Glove award in each of the past three campaigns.
His importance is reflected in Arsenal's defensive record, with the Gunners conceding just seven league goals this season.
Former Arsenal striker Ian Wright also highlighted the potential impact of losing Raya, describing the situation as a major concern given the goalkeeper's importance to the team.
Arsenal's goalkeeping options are relatively limited, with Kepa next in line and Illan Meslier providing further cover after arriving on a free transfer in the summer.
The injury adds to Arteta's concerns, with Bukayo Saka and Martin Zubimendi also among those sidelined, although William Saliba recently returned to the matchday squad.
Despite Raya's departure, Arsenal rescued a point against Newcastle through Noni Madueke's equaliser after goals from Harvey Barnes and Malick Thiaw had overturned Eberechi Eze's opener. The result left the Gunners six points clear at the top of the Premier League.