Former All Black says New Zealand have regressed since SA teams left Super Rugby

Former All Black says New Zealand have regressed since SA teams left Super Rugby

Mesley recently said that he had no interest in getting South African teams back into Super Rugby Pacific.

He reasoned that fixtures involving teams from the Rainbow Nation did not get good television ratings or attract big crowds to stadiums.

However, speaking to the Rivals podcast, Kirwan suggested that Mesley's comments may have been entirely based on facts.

"That is nonsense and I think he probably just had to say it as the CEO of Super Rugby. I can understand that to a degree, but I cannot agree with him," Kirwan said.

"I still feel that if we want to properly develop our players on this side of the world for the challenges of Test rugby, we have to let them play against South African teams.

"We have gone backwards, and when I say that, I mean the step up for some of our players from Super Rugby to Test rugby is currently too big."

Kirwan also believes the overall standard of Super Rugby has dropped significantly since South African teams left the competition.

"I just want to know: What has become of Super Rugby? Is it a competitive competition and are we doing rugby development at a high-performance level to try and prepare players to play Test rugby?

"Then I would also like to see the data [Mesley talks about] on how attendance and interest have increased. I don't think he is telling the truth."

Related News

Rampant Hurricanes crush Chiefs to storm to 2026 Super Rugby Pacific title

Rampant Hurricanes crush Chiefs to storm to 2026 Super Rugby Pacific title

  • 7 hours ago

The Hurricanes produced an utterly dominant attacking display to thrash the Chiefs 60-5 and claim the 2026 Super Rugby Pacific title at Sky Stadium in Wellington.

All Black legend wants coach Dave Rennie to emulate Rassie Erasmus' bravery

All Black legend wants coach Dave Rennie to emulate Rassie Erasmus' bravery

  • 2 days ago

Former All Black Sir John Kirwan believes New Zealand coach Dave Rennie cannot adopt a risk-free approach if he wants to be successful.

England dealt fresh bowling blow as Ollie Robinson ruled out of second New Zealand Test

England dealt fresh bowling blow as Ollie Robinson ruled out of second New Zealand Test

  • 5 days ago

England's preparations for the second Test against New Zealand have suffered another setback after Ollie Robinson was ruled out with a knee problem, leaving the hosts short on experience ahead of Wednesday's clash at The Oval.

Kieran Read explains why Springboks hold the upper hand over All Blacks

Kieran Read explains why Springboks hold the upper hand over All Blacks

  • 9 days ago

Former All Blacks captain Kieran Read believes the Springboks' unwavering identity and proven ability to thrive under pressure are key factors separating them from New Zealand's current side.